On the HahaFiction shelf
A Deadly Education
by Naomi Novik
The Scholomance · Book 1 · 2020
Galadriel Higgins, usually called El, has enough destructive magic to be a catastrophe. She would prefer to survive school without becoming one. At the Scholomance, monsters stalk the students, alliances affect who lives, and a reputation for dangerous power is hardly a social advantage. Orion Lake keeps rescuing El, which she finds infuriating.
From the publisher’s blurb
“Everyone loves Orion Lake. Everyone else, that is.”Read the full description at Del Rey, publisher description
Paid link · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure
What makes it funny?
In the opening chapter, El wants a spell to clean monster remains out of her room. The magic offers ways to raise an army or enslave people instead. Her talent for devastation is spectacularly inconvenient when she needs basic housekeeping. Readers single out her snide comments and prickly inner monologue, along with the friction between El and Orion, whose heroics earn him very little gratitude from her.
The comedy at work
El narrates as though she is arguing her case to someone who has already misunderstood her. She corrects assumptions, anticipates objections, and takes offense at the role of grateful rescuee. El keeps an impatient tally of what each rescue costs her. Alongside the humiliation, there’s the broken door. Her sarcasm coexists with a serious refusal to use her power at other people’s expense.
Try this if…
There is plenty here for readers who like a difficult narrator with moral resolve. El’s barbed perspective and her changing relationship with Orion are the main draws. The school’s unequal access to protection and connections also gives readers interested in privilege something more pointed than the usual dangerous lessons.
Good to know
This adult fantasy follows teenage students and combines sharp humor with lethal monsters and the prospect of mass destruction. El spends substantial time explaining the school and its magic. Some readers enjoy living inside her sarcastic commentary. Others find the exposition slow. Fantasy Cafe liked the developing relationships but found the dark jokes largely unamusing and the narration too long-winded.
A few distinguishing details
- Destructive magic that complicates ordinary housekeeping
- A narrator irritated by the school’s celebrated rescuer
- Survival alliances shaped by unequal access to protection
More funny fantasy
Sources & further reading
- Publisher and opening chapter
Publisher
- Reader discussion
Reader discussion
- Review: Fantasy Cafe
Review
- Publisher: Scholomance book one
Publisher
Something we should correct? Let us know.




