Skip to content
HahaFictionSuggest a book

What to read next

Books Like A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder

Amateur detectives, dark jokes, and one very determined school project.

Pip Fitz-Amobi could have picked an easier school project. Instead she reopens a murder case her town considers solved. The more she treats it like an assignment she has to get right, the harder it is to believe the story everyone else has agreed on.

Most of the sleuths here are well past seventeen. We looked for people with Pip’s habit of asking one more question when it would be easier to go home, from a private eye who keeps files on her dates to a mom who has till nursery school lets out.

Paid links · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure

  1. Cover of The Ex-Girlfriend Murder Club by Gloria Chao
    01

    The Ex-Girlfriend Murder Club

    by Gloria Chao

    Start with Kat Hu. She’s a chemistry researcher who learns her boyfriend has two other girlfriends. The three women get as far as planning revenge before they find him dead. They have good reason to look for the killer themselves, since the evidence points their way.

    Kat approaches bad luck as if she could explain it with a scientific law. Then she tries to smooth things over with a lab technician by making another joke about somebody’s name. It’s the closest match for a sleuth who thinks her way into trouble, with more banter and some sexual references.

    About the book Search on Amazon

  2. Cover of The Spellman Files by Lisa Lutz
    02

    The Spellman Files

    by Lisa Lutz

    Izzy Spellman files reports on her exes, right down to their last words as a couple. To get out of her parents' detective agency, she has to finish a cold missing-person case, and these are people who think a date warrants a background check. If you liked following Pip’s investigation as she put it together, wait until you see what Izzy puts in a footnote.

    About the book Search on Amazon

  3. Cover of Finlay Donovan Is Killing It by Elle Cosimano
    03

    Finlay Donovan Is Killing It

    by Elle Cosimano

    A stranger overhears Finlay talking to her agent about a book and offers her $50,000 to kill a husband. Finlay has no plans to become an assassin, but she winds up with a body to deal with alongside work deadlines and child care. Read this for the farce. It takes a playful tone with some rough material, including drugging and sexual violence.

    About the book Search on Amazon

  4. Cover of A Most Agreeable Murder by Julia Seales
    04

    A Most Agreeable Murder

    by Julia Seales

    Nobody can tell that Beatrice Steele has embroidered a portrait of her favorite detective. They think it’s a potato. Her family is counting on a ball to help secure a wealthy marriage. Then a bachelor dies, and at last there’s a use for all those crime reports she’s been reading.

    About the book Search on Amazon

  5. Cover of Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone by Benjamin Stevenson
    05

    Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone

    by Benjamin Stevenson

    Ernest Cunningham writes guides to constructing a mystery. When a body turns up in the snow at his family reunion, he has a case of his own. If you kept stopping to work through Pip’s clues, start here. Ernie tells you how he’s laid out the evidence and even gives you page numbers for the deaths. He does admit to lying about his age in the hope that a movie star will play him.

    About the book Search on Amazon

  6. Cover of The Bandit Queens by Parini Shroff
    06

    The Bandit Queens

    by Parini Shroff

    The best gossip on the list belongs to Geeta. Her husband walked out, and she’s had a quieter life since the village decided she’d killed him. Then other wives start asking for help with theirs. This is a revenge story with domestic abuse at its center. At a loan meeting, all Geeta wants is for a lizard to fall on the group’s bully.

    About the book Search on Amazon

  7. Cover of The Automatic Detective by A. Lee Martinez
    07

    The Automatic Detective

    by A. Lee Martinez

    Mack Megaton was built to lead a robot army. Now he drives a cab, and the company insists on a real bow tie. He asks his neighbor to tie it every morning, which is how he finds out something’s happened to her family. Mack sounds like an old private eye, even when he’s worrying about the price of electricity.

    About the book Search on Amazon

  8. Cover of The Eyre Affair by Jasper Fforde
    08

    The Eyre Affair

    by Jasper Fforde

    In Thursday Next’s Britain, authors have trading cards and a criminal can kidnap Jane Eyre straight out of the novel. Thursday goes into fiction after him. Save this one for when you’re happy to take a few detours during a case. The time police can retire in any era they like.

    About the book Search on Amazon

  9. Cover of The Deep End by Julie Mulhern
    09

    The Deep End

    by Julie Mulhern

    It’s 1974 and Ellison Russell goes for a dawn swim at the country club. The body in the pool belongs to her husband’s mistress. Ellison figures a public argument with her husband will give everyone something to review over the phone the next morning. The blackmail and marital cruelty push this one past the usual cozy.

    About the book Search on Amazon

  10. Cover of Goodnight Nobody by Jennifer Weiner
    10

    Goodnight Nobody

    by Jennifer Weiner

    Kate Klein arrives for lunch and finds Kitty Cavanaugh stabbed to death. She has three mornings a week to look for the killer while her kids are at nursery school. Pick this for the Connecticut playground politics. Kate notices the other moms' monogrammed silk diaper bags and keeps a few lollipops handy for bribery.

    About the book Search on Amazon

  11. Cover of One Death at a Time by Abbi Waxman
    11

    One Death at a Time

    by Abbi Waxman

    When a man sets fire to some pamphlets at a recovery meeting, Natasha Mason puts out the flames and the facilitator tells him to apologize. That turns out to be the easy part of being a sobriety sponsor. A body in former actress Julia Mann’s pool sends the two women undercover around Los Angeles, with plenty of time to disagree about how much help Julia needs.

    About the book Search on Amazon

  12. Cover of Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency by Douglas Adams
    12

    Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency

    by Douglas Adams

    The wildcard. Dirk’s murder investigation has room for a ghost and the poet Coleridge, and the narrator pauses long enough to decide that Dirk’s hat would look better on a bedside lamp.

    About the book Search on Amazon

Another guide to try

Books like

Listen for the Lie

by Amy Tintera

She might have done it, and you still want to hear her side.

Funny Mystery10 picks

Every book here has a full profile on HahaFiction, with the sources behind it. How we choose books

Know a book that belongs here?

Readers, authors, and enthusiastic friends. Tell us about it.

Suggest a book