On the HahaFiction shelf
The Big Over Easy
Nursery Crime · Book 1 · 2005
Humpty Dumpty lands in the Reading morgue in pieces. Detective Inspector Jack Spratt and his new sergeant, Mary Mary, suspect foul play. The egg had money, a criminal record, and an elaborate personal life. Finding out who wanted him dead takes the Nursery Crime Division into some of the city’s most respectable businesses.
From the publisher’s blurb
“Welcome to the seedy underbelly of nursery crime.”Read the full description at Penguin Books
Paid link · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure
What makes it funny?
When Mary interviews for a transfer, her superintendent asks where she’s published her cases and whether the television adaptation ran in prime time. She has a cable documentary to her name. Judging by his face, she might as well have said she’d never made an arrest.
The comedy at work
Fforde gives nursery-rhyme characters the full machinery of a police investigation. A pathologist pieces Humpty’s shell back together, and the Three Little Pigs case still hangs over Spratt’s career. The detectives keep a straight face, even when the evidence sends them looking into the black market for béarnaise sauce.
Try this if…
There’s a proper murder puzzle here for readers who like dry British delivery, ludicrous suspects, and detective-fiction references. The Observer reviewer enjoyed the book as a whodunit in its own right.
Good to know
The wordplay comes thick and fast. The Kirkus reviewer found it ingeniously funny at first and felt the effect wore off as the case went on.
Keep reading
More in Nursery Crime
The series continues with one more book on our shelf.
Paid links · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure
A few distinguishing details
- A detective’s reputation can ride on whether a case makes good television.
More funny private eye & detective

Bad Monkey
Carl Hiaasen
Private eye & detective · Dark comedy
Audiobook

The Automatic Detective
A. Lee Martinez
Comic noir · Private eye & detective
Audiobook

The Trees
Percival Everett
Comic noir · Private eye & detective
Audiobook

The Great American Deception
Scott Stein
Private eye & detective · Absurdism
Audiobook
Sources & further reading
- Hachette UK edition
Publisher
- Open Library’s 2005 edition record
Library catalog
- Penguin Books edition
Publisher
- Penguin Books reader’s guide
Publisher
- Kirkus Reviews
Review
- Penguin Books opening excerpt
Publisher
Something we should correct? Let us know.

