On the HahaFiction shelf
Jackaby
by William Ritter
Jackaby · Book 1 · 2014
Abigail Rook reaches New Fiddleham in 1892 needing work and finds an employer whose specialty is everything the local police refuse to believe in. R.F. Jackaby can see supernatural creatures. Abigail has the more practical talent of noticing what is in front of him. Their first case together is a series of killings that Jackaby thinks has a nonhuman culprit.
From the publisher’s blurb
“Abigail has a gift for noticing ordinary but important details”Read the full description at Little, Brown Books for Young Readers, publisher description
Paid link · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure
What makes it funny?
Jackaby can recognize a supernatural threat and still forget to tell his new assistant that a ghost lives upstairs. The Historical Novel Society singles out that errand, which sends Abigail into a hasty retreat, as an example of the book’s macabre humor. Bookyurt points to a former assistant who now waddles around as waterfowl. Readers also enjoy Jackaby’s casual attitude to the bizarre and the energy of Abigail’s narration.
The comedy at work
Abigail tells the story, giving the grand detective someone observant enough to question his habits. His expertise leaves conspicuous gaps in ordinary social behavior, while her common sense has genuine investigative value. Bookyurt describes her reaching for explanations familiar from detective stories, such as salt water and traces of clay, when she tries to follow one of Jackaby’s deductions.
Try this if…
Readers who enjoy a capable Watson figure may find Abigail especially appealing. She wants an adventure of her own and has a knack for spotting clues her employer overlooks. The partnership takes shape in a small New England town. Readers single out the dry treatment of impossible events as part of the fun.
Good to know
Serial murder and unsettling encounters give the jokes a macabre setting. Some readers found the voice suited younger teens, although the publisher markets it as young adult. Bookyurt enjoyed the adventure but found the detective types familiar and the mystery easy to anticipate, a useful caveat if an elusive solution matters more to you than the partnership.
A few distinguishing details
- An assistant whose ordinary observation complements supernatural sight
- A Sherlockian investigation in 1892 New England
- Deadpan household mishaps alongside serial murder
More funny private eye & detective

Bad Monkey
Carl Hiaasen
Private eye & detective · Dark comedy
Audiobook

The Automatic Detective
A. Lee Martinez
Comic noir · Private eye & detective
Audiobook

The Trees
Percival Everett
Comic noir · Private eye & detective
Audiobook

The Great American Deception
Scott Stein
Private eye & detective · Absurdism
Audiobook
Sources & further reading
- Publisher: Jackaby series
Publisher
- Publisher: original ebook
Publisher
- Reader discussion
Reader discussion
- Review: Bookyurt
Review
- Publisher: Jackaby
Publisher
- Review: Historical Novel Society
Review
Something we should correct? Let us know.
