What to read next
Books Like Finlay Donovan Is Killing It
Stressed moms and bodies that won’t wait until after pickup.
Finlay Donovan has a preschool haircut disaster on her hands before a stranger offers her $50,000 to kill a man. The stranger has overheard Finlay talking through a book with her agent and mistaken her for a hitwoman. Finlay has no plans to kill anybody. She still winds up with a body to deal with, and she still has deadlines and kids.
If you liked watching those problems compete for space on the same calendar, go straight to Dial A for Aunties. There are quieter options here too, including a murder club that started out as something to do at the retirement village.
Paid links · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure
- 01
Vera Wong’s Unsolicited Advice for Murderers
by Jesse Q. SutantoVera finds a dead man on her tea shop floor and pockets his flash drive. Before long she’s feeding the people she suspects might want it back. It’s cozier than Finlay and a good place to start if you came for the unlikely friendships. Vera also texts her son at 4:31 a.m. to tell him he sleeps too late.
- 02
The Thursday Murder Club
by Richard OsmanJoyce can get from a conversation about a fatal stabbing to lunch by way of a department store kitchen knife. She’s one of four retirement village friends who meet to talk over cold cases. A murder nearby gives them a chance to see if they can get ahead of the police. Save this one for when you’d rather solve the murder than help hide the body.
- 03
The Spellman Files
by Lisa LutzThe Spellmans run a detective agency, and nobody in the family gets to be off duty. Izzy has one last missing person case to finish before she can quit. If you want another narrator who can tell on herself without quite meaning to, she’s your best bet. Her files on old boyfriends include their last remarks before the breakup.
- 04
A Bad Day for Sunshine
by Darynda JonesSunshine Vicram comes home to New Mexico as sheriff thanks to an election her parents arranged without her. A stolen rooster is one of her new responsibilities. A missing teenager is another, and that case brings back Sunshine’s own abduction. Go here for the teasing between a mother and daughter if you’re also up for a harder case.
- 05
Riley Thorn and the Dead Guy Next Door
by Lucy ScorePretending to date a private investigator sounds like a lot of work when you’re broke, newly suspected of murder and trying to ignore your psychic visions. Riley does it anyway. Here’s the one to pick if you want the flirting to get as much room as the case.
- 06
Dial A for Aunties
by Jesse Q. SutantoMeddy calls her family when her blind date ends in an accidental killing. Her mom and aunties help hide the body, which gets to the wedding they’re catering in a cake cooler. This is the closest match for the part of Finlay’s story where having a corpse on your hands doesn’t get you out of doing your job. Meddy also has to get through the wedding with her old college boyfriend there.
Meddy’s date tries to sexually assault her before she kills him. The cover-up plays as farce.
- 07
Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone
by Benjamin StevensonErnest Cunningham gives you the page numbers for the deaths and admits to making himself younger so a movie star might play him. He writes how-to guides for mystery writers. Then a man turns up dead in the snow at his family reunion. If you like pausing to see how the author set a trap for you, Ernie will pause right along with you.
- 08
Merit Badge Murder
by Leslie LangtryMerry Wrath has left the CIA to lead Girl Scouts in Iowa. When she finds a dead enemy agent at camp, she covers the corpse with a games parachute and gets the girls doing something else. Merry has more practice keeping secrets than Finlay does. Running a troop gives her plenty of paperwork and no particular help remembering the girls’ names.
- 09
Do Butlers Burgle Banks?
by P. G. WodehouseThe lightest one here. Mike needs someone to break into his own bank. His new butler happens to be a burglar who took the job to get some peace and quiet.
- 10
A Beginner's Guide to Breaking and Entering
by Andrew Hunter MurrayAl deals with London rents by letting himself into rich people’s second homes. He takes pride in leaving them tidy. When a homeowner is killed, Al and three fellow housebreakers start asking questions before the police can pin the death on them. Al types the story from prison and wonders if getting paid for it would count as profiting from crime.
- 11
A Good Person
by Kirsten KingLillian tries an online hex tutorial after a breakup. Then her ex dies and she appoints herself the grieving girlfriend. Take this one for deadpan unease. Even at her office birthday party, she won’t make a wish over a cake with a misspelled name in case somebody else gets it.
Another guide to try
Books like
One for the Money
by Janet Evanovich
For Stephanie Plum fans who want more broke sleuths, nosy families and one detective who’s a dog.
Funny Mystery11 picks
Every book here has a full profile on HahaFiction, with the sources behind it. How we choose books












