
On the HahaFiction shelf
Who Loves You Best
by Marilyn Simon Rothstein
Jodi Wexler leaves her Florida podiatry practice and a newly unemployed husband behind for a visit to the Berkshires. Her daughter needs help with eight-year-old Macallan, and Jodi is eager for time alone with her granddaughter. She arrives to find that Di has moved in, Grannie Annie is already involved, and her daughter’s marriage is in trouble.
From the author’s blurb
“As the competition for Macallan’s attention among the three “grandmas” increases, Lisa drops a bomb about her life that changes everything.”Read the full description at Marilyn Simon Rothstein, book description
Paid link · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure
What makes it funny?
Di has plenty of rules, starting with what Macallan is supposed to call her. She goes by Di. The one who actually answers to Grannie Annie is 27 and dating Macallan’s grandfather.
The comedy at work
Jodi is visiting from out of state and wants to make up for all the time she’s missed. Di gets the benefits of being local, and Annie already has a close relationship with Macallan. Put the three on the same childcare assignment and even deciding who gets time with the kid can turn into an argument over who’s best at loving her.
Try this if…
LibraryThing readers found the grandmothers’ rivalry funny and recognized the family obligations underneath it. This is a family comedy for anyone interested in what happens when the person who always drops everything for her children starts asking what she wants for herself.
More funny family comedy
Sources & further reading
- LibraryThing reader reviews
Reader discussion
- Jewish Book Council review
Review
- Paperback edition and trade reviews
Book information
- Marilyn Simon Rothstein’s book description
Author commentary
Something we should correct? Let us know.



