A typographic placeholder. Cover art is not available.
On the HahaFiction shelf
The Yiddish Policemen's Union
In this alternate present, Jewish refugees built a self-governing district in Sitka, Alaska. Its lease is about to expire, leaving detective Meyer Landsman uncertain about his job and home. A murder in his shabby hotel gives him a case he refuses to surrender, even with his ex-wife now running the police force.
Paid link · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure
What makes it funny?
Landsman asks the hotel manager whether he touched anything in the dead man’s room. The manager jokes that he helped himself to the valuables. Their exhausted professional exchange gives the opening murder scene its dry edge. Readers also single out Chabon’s Yiddish-inflected wordplay and elaborate similes.
The comedy at work
Noir conventions give Landsman reasons to be cynical; the narration gives him precise, inventive ways to express it. Russ Allbery’s review praises the gallows humor woven into descriptions and the sarcastic comments that build across scenes.
Try this if…
A strong fit for readers who enjoy detective fiction as much for its language and setting as for solving the case. The reader report describes sustained wit with a bleak undertow. Familiarity with Yiddish may add another pleasure, though Allbery describes following it through context on a first reading.
Good to know
This standalone includes murder, alcoholism, and a suicide theme. Allbery notes that the outcome is less fully resolved than a conventional mystery might lead you to expect.
A few distinguishing details
- A Jewish Alaskan district approaching the end of its lease
- A detective whose ex-wife has become his boss
- A hotel murder told through dry banter and verbal invention
More funny alternate history
Sources & further reading
- Russ Allbery review
Review
- Authorized excerpt and edition record
Book information
- Archived Muse reader report
Reader discussion
Something we should correct? Let us know.


