On the HahaFiction shelf

The Fraud

Audiobook available · 12 hr 25 min

In 1873, Eliza Touchet keeps house for her cousin by marriage, the fading novelist William Ainsworth. The Tichborne inheritance trial draws her beyond his literary circle to Andrew Bogle, a formerly enslaved Jamaican man whose testimony supports a butcher claiming to be an aristocratic heir. The courtroom dispute connects lives separated by class and empire.

From the publisher’s blurb

“Truth and fiction. Jamaica and Britain. Who gets to tell their story?”
Read the full description at Penguin Random House publisher description
Search on Amazon

Paid link · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure

What makes it funny?

Ainsworth's library is so heavy that the floor gives way beneath it. Eliza's dry responses to the workman turn a structural problem into a judgment on her employer's literary output. Looking after the author also means scanning newspapers for other writers' successes that might upset him.

The comedy at work

Smith shifts between Eliza's skeptical judgments and a young workman's practical view of an impressive household. Faced with pictures of Venice, Joseph wonders how anyone tiles steps underwater. Literary prestige and cultivated manners look different to the people who must manage egos or repair floors.

Try this if…

The appeal includes prickly literary company and a woman unimpressed by its reputation. Readers interested in who gets believed, who gets to tell a story and how class shapes those decisions have more to follow than the courtroom claim alone.

Good to know

Short scenes move across time, from the trial and Eliza's memories to Bogle's ancestry and life under enslavement. Racism, sexual relationships, BDSM references and strong profanity accompany the literary satire.

A few distinguishing details

  • A novelist's books literally bring down part of his house
  • A Victorian claimant trial connects literary London with Jamaican plantation history

More funny contemporary & literary

Browse this genre

Sources & further reading

Something we should correct? Let us know.

Know a book that belongs here?

Authors, readers, enthusiastic friends. We’re all ears.

Suggest a book