On the HahaFiction shelf
The Editor
James Smale has sold a novel and acquired an unexpected problem: his editor is Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis. His thinly disguised family story needs an ending, but his mother has good reason to resent the manuscript. In 1990s New York, James must face the people he has written about before he can finish the book.
From the publisher’s blurb
“a struggling writer who gets his big break”Read the full description at G.P. Putnam’s Sons publisher description
Paid link · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure
What makes it funny?
A publishing meeting is difficult enough without discovering that the woman assessing your sentences is Jackie O. James takes that disbelief home to his partner, Daniel. Readers describe a sly, warm voice and laughter mixed with tears, and connect it with Rowley’s Lily and the Octopus and The Guncle.
The comedy at work
Rowley puts a nervous novelist opposite an editor whose fame makes ordinary professional composure almost impossible. James can expose his family in fiction more readily than he can speak frankly to his mother. Jackie’s practical demands keep drawing those two problems together.
Try this if…
There’s a particular appeal here for readers who like publishing stories and awkward mother–son relationships, with an unlikely friendship offering a way toward reconciliation.
Good to know
Expect family estrangement and grief, including conflict around coming out and a father’s abandonment. Reactions to the family plot are divided: some readers prefer Jackie’s scenes, while Kirkus found the opening jokes labored despite admiring her portrayal.
A few distinguishing details
- A debut novelist whose editor is Jackie Onassis
- A manuscript’s ending entangled with its author’s family
More funny family comedy
Sources & further reading
- Mary E. Trimble review
Review
- Publisher
Publisher
- Kirkus review
Review
- Reader discussion
Reader discussion
Something we should correct? Let us know.




