On the HahaFiction shelf
The Commitments
by Roddy Doyle
Barrytown Trilogy · Book 1 · 1987
Outspan and Derek are talking about starting a synth-pop band when they ask Jimmy Rabbitte for advice. Jimmy takes over and points them toward the records he loves, by Sam Cooke and Otis Redding. With the older horn player Joey ‘The Lips’ Fagan to show them how it’s done, these North Dublin musicians set out to give the city a soul band.
From the publisher’s blurb
“Doyle writes about the band with a fan’s enthusiasm and about Dublin with a native’s cheerful knowingness.”Read the full description at Vintage
Paid link · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure
What makes it funny?
The musicians treat soul with reverence and still find room to give Percy Sledge’s ‘When a Man Loves a Woman’ an extra line about taking a date to the zoo. Readers single out the way the bandmates talk to each other. They can go from an earnest lesson on soul to a volley of insults without missing a beat.
The comedy at work
Jimmy’s place in the band depends on what he knows about music, so he holds forth while the others learn to play. Joey has enough stories about famous musicians to sound like the real thing. When he says Joe Tex may call him for a gig, Jimmy remembers hearing that Tex is dead.
Try this if…
The rise of a band gives a short book a lot of momentum, and readers describe flying through the dialogue once their ears adjust to the Dublin slang. The Blues Brothers and The Full Monty come up as points of comparison in reader discussions about the book.
Good to know
Expect frequent swearing in Dublin dialect and some racist language. Doyle follows young people with limited job prospects, and their joy in the music shares space with frustration. The novel was adapted into a film in 1991.
A few distinguishing details
- North Dublin’s would-be soul band
- A Percy Sledge cover that takes a detour to the zoo
More funny contemporary
Sources & further reading
- Kirkus review
Review
- Vintage book page
Publisher
- Kevin McNeilly on the novel
Review
- National Library of Ireland finding aid
Library catalog
- Archived Muse reader report
Reader discussion
- Publishers Weekly review
Review
Something we should correct? Let us know.




