A typographic placeholder. Cover art is not available.
On the HahaFiction shelf
The Christmas Appeal
by Janice Hallett
The Appeal · Book 1.5 · 2023
The Fairway Players need a new church roof, so they’re putting on Jack and the Beanstalk. Rehearsals bring rival ambitions, an inconveniently large prop and very little seasonal goodwill. A dead Santa adds a mystery for lawyers Femi and Charlotte to unravel through the group’s emails, letters and transcripts.
From the publisher’s blurb
“One dead Santa. A town full of suspects.”Read the full description at Viper, publisher description
Paid link · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure
What makes it funny?
Celia’s Christmas update boasts about an improved production of Glengarry Glen Ross with the swearing removed and a happy ending added. A private reply supplies the missing detail: David Mamet’s response came from his lawyer. Her son’s exclusive driving course receives a similar correction.
The comedy at work
Hallett lets readers compare the version people circulate with the version they tell someone else privately. Polite group emails sit beside furious messages, and the arguments over a volunteer production accumulate into farce.
Try this if…
The pleasures are partly those of overhearing a disastrous committee meeting. Readers who like theatrical ambition, social snobbery and clues hidden among ordinary messages have a short holiday mystery to work through.
Good to know
BOLO Books says the novella can be read independently, but it reveals surprises from The Appeal. Read that novel first if you want to preserve its mystery. Expect a story assembled from written exchanges, with a corpse and a potentially asbestos-filled beanstalk among the production problems.
A few distinguishing details
- A Christmas round robin corrected by private footnotes
- An amateur pantomime and a dead Santa
More funny cozy mystery

Merit Badge Murder
Leslie Langtry
Amateur sleuth · Cozy mystery

Finlay Donovan Is Killing It
Elle Cosimano
Amateur sleuth · Cozy mystery
The Accidental Medium
Tracy Whitwell
Cozy mystery · Paranormal mystery

The Case of the Missing Servant
Tarquin Hall
Cozy mystery · Private eye & detective
Sources & further reading
- BOLO Books review
Review
- Publisher sample
Reading sample
- Publisher
Publisher
- Reading Reality review
Review
Something we should correct? Let us know.