Skip to content
HahaFictionSuggest a book

On the HahaFiction shelf

Modern Lovers

by Emma Straub

Elizabeth, Andrew, and Zoe played in Kitty’s Mustache at Oberlin. Years later they live near each other in Brooklyn, and a film producer wants the rights to the song that made their late bandmate Lydia famous. While the adults pick through the history of the band, Harry and Ruby, the two families’ teenagers, start seeing each other.

From the publisher’s blurb

“what it means to finally grow up, well after adulthood has set in”
Read the full description at Riverhead Books
Search on Amazon

Paid link · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure

What makes it funny?

Before Ruby’s graduation ceremony, Elizabeth hears her son swear and asks if that’s the name of Ruby’s boyfriend, Dust. When Harry tackles Dust right there in the school lobby, Ruby gives the crowd a beauty queen’s wave. Readers single out how natural the dialogue sounds even in exchanges this awkward.

The comedy at work

The former bandmates have spent years trying to hang on to the idea that they’re still cool. Straub lets their kids run into the same trouble in real time, while the grown-ups have a whole Brooklyn summer to worry about what theirs amounted to.

Try this if…

Readers who go to Anne Tyler for a close look at family habits may enjoy what Straub does with two households near enough to watch each other unravel. The humor is warm and wry, with enough Ditmas Park detail to give the families somewhere particular to be awkward.

Good to know

The story includes teenage sexuality, marital strain, infidelity, and a past overdose. Some readers found the adults’ comfortable Brooklyn circle insulated and hard to get invested in.

A few distinguishing details

  • A request for one old song sends three former college bandmates back into their shared history.

More funny coming of age

Browse this genre

Sources & further reading

Something we should correct? Let us know.

Know a book that belongs here?

Readers, authors, and enthusiastic friends. Tell us about it.

Suggest a book