On the HahaFiction shelf
Jenny Cooper Has a Secret
by Joy Fielding
Linda Davidson visits a memory care facility to see her oldest friend, who no longer recognizes her. That’s where 92-year-old Jenny Cooper tells Linda that she kills people. Linda figures Jenny has confused memory and imagination until another resident dies. The more specific Jenny gets about the men she says she’s killed, the harder it is for Linda to dismiss her.
From the author’s blurb
“a woman must decide whether she can believe a dementia patient who claims to have a dark secret.”Read the full description at Joy Fielding, book description
Paid link · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure
What makes it funny?
The first meeting hops from introductions to a compliment on Linda’s yellow dress. Jenny mishears the name of the department store, takes offense, and then gets straight back to wanting to tell her secret. Fielding lets the ordinary awkwardness of meeting a stranger carry right through to the confession.
The comedy at work
Jenny says alarming things in the same matter-of-fact voice she uses for small talk. Linda has a dry running commentary of her own. She can hear the irony in calling a memory care facility Legacy Place, and she notices how quickly a thought about her age gets her counting the inches she’s lost. Her wit gives the visits a warmth that makes her growing fondness for Jenny easy to understand.
Try this if…
The question of whether Jenny’s telling the truth gives the book its suspense. The reviewers who enjoyed the friendship found room for tenderness and wit inside that mystery. Linda is a widow watching her life get smaller, and every visit gives her something new to talk about.
Good to know
The novel deals with bereavement, dementia, domestic abuse, and murder. Its humor can sit very close to those subjects.
More funny amateur sleuth
Sources & further reading
- Joy Fielding’s book page
Author commentary
- Publishers Weekly
Review
- Bookreporter
Review
- Ballantine Books edition and opening chapter
Publisher
Something we should correct? Let us know.




