On the HahaFiction shelf
Evvie Drake Starts Over
by Linda Holmes
Everyone in Evvie Drake’s Maine town thinks she has withdrawn because she misses her late husband. She lets them think so. When Dean Tenney rents the apartment attached to her house, she gains a tenant with a public failure of his own: a once-successful pitcher who can no longer throw straight. They agree to avoid the husband and the baseball talk, then grow too close to leave those subjects alone.
From the publisher’s blurb
“the two most unlikely comebacks of the year”Read the full description at Ballantine Books publisher description
Paid link · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure
What makes it funny?
Readers keep pointing to the conversations, describing frequent laughter from Evvie and Dean’s banter. Their pact creates an awkward intimacy: each knows the subject the other wants to avoid, and each begins wanting to help anyway. Book By Book singles out that wit alongside the warmth.
The comedy at work
Holmes gives two people stalled by very different troubles room to talk, tease, and get interested in each other. Their affection complicates the rules they made as housemates. The romance also leaves them responsible for their own recovery, a feature the Book By Book review particularly values.
Try this if…
For a romance built on friendship and sharp conversation, this offers a gentle setting with difficult adult decisions. Reader reactions point toward the appeal of Abbi Waxman and Taylor Jenkins Reid, also naming Jasmine Guillory and Maria Semple as possible audiences.
Good to know
The romance drives the story. Bereavement, guilt, and emotional abuse in Evvie’s former marriage matter to the backstory, despite the warm tone. Her husband dies in a car accident just as she is preparing to leave him.
A few distinguishing details
- Two housemates agree to avoid the subjects defining their lives
- A pitcher with the yips and a widow keeping a secret
More funny contemporary romance
Sources & further reading
- Publisher
Publisher
- Book By Book review
Review
- Reader discussion
Reader discussion
Something we should correct? Let us know.




