
On the HahaFiction shelf
Critical Failures
by Robert Bevan
Caverns and Creatures · Book 1
Audiobook available · 8 hr 4 min
Tim, Dave, Julian and Cooper mock their new game master, then find themselves inside the fantasy game as the characters they created. Surviving magic and monsters now requires living with decisions they made at the table, as well as surviving each other’s company.
Paid link · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure
What makes it funny?
Character creation acquires uncomfortable consequences. Tim has a halfling’s small voice, Dave is an armored dwarf, and Cooper has tusks and bowel trouble. Cooper also has to deal with a head he chopped off when the violence was still part of a game.
The comedy at work
A choice that costs nothing at a gaming table can leave a player physically stuck once the game is real. Bevan adds the friends’ petty arguments and insults to the danger, letting their usual behavior complicate the work of keeping themselves alive.
Try this if…
Familiarity with tabletop fantasy gives the jokes about rules and character builds extra context. The appeal depends heavily on enjoying foolish adventurers, insulting exchanges and crude humor.
Good to know
Heavy profanity, offensive jokes and bodily humor are central to the book. The setup includes gastrointestinal trouble and a severed head.
Keep reading
More in Caverns and Creatures
The series continues with 10 more books on our shelf.

Book 2Critical Failures II

Book 3Critical Failures III

Book 4Critical Failures IV

Book 5Critical Failures V

Book 6Critical Failures VI

Book 7Critical Failures VII

Book 8Critical Failures VIII

Book 9Critical Failures IX

Book 10Critical Failures X

Book 11Critical Failures XI
Paid links · We earn commissions from qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure
A few distinguishing details
- Gamers physically stuck with their own character builds
- An adventuring party still arguing like friends around a gaming table
Keep following the thread
Reading guides that start from this book or include it.
More funny portal fantasy LitRPG

Derek's Dungeon Depot
Little Lynx
Portal fantasy · Progression fantasy
Audiobook

Master of Puppets
Eric Ugland
Portal fantasy · Progression fantasy
Audiobook

Arrival: A Humorous Isekai LitRPG
Icalos
Portal fantasy · Dry wit

An Unexpected Hero
Rhett C. Bruno & Jaime Castle
Portal fantasy · Progression fantasy
Audiobook
Sources & further reading
- Bookseller bibliographic listing
Book information
- Swords & Spectres review
Review
- Author’s printed books
Author commentary
- Audiobook listing
Book information
Something we should correct? Let us know.


